Chapter 11

The atmosphere in O"Reilly"s was electric. The Ghouls walked in, followed by a round of cheers. Cruz and Easton both bowed before joining Cat and Shaw in the corner.

Toby did his own wave to the crowd before joining Eden and me at the bar. He draped his arm over my shoulder and kissed my cheek.

"Good game tonight," I said. I nestled into him before Eden made a face and slipped away.

"Something I said?" he drawled.

"She"s just giving us some space." I gestured to the bar attendant to make us a round of drinks. He nodded and placed a beer in front of Toby and wine in front of me. I nodded my thanks and tapped my card to pay.

"I appreciate her doing that." Toby picked up his drink and offered me a toast.

"To the first win of the season," I said. They"d scraped through in overtime with a score of five goals to four, but it was still a win.

"The first of many," he said. "We"re just warming up around here." He grinned and knocked back half his drink in one go.

"I"ll drink to that." I took a smaller sip. I didn"t want to get shitfaced. The last time I did, I threw up on someone"s shoes. I didn"t even know who. I didn"t need that kind of embarrassment in my life more than once.

"Cole." Toby gestured him over. "You were on fire tonight." He offered the defenceman a fist bump.

Cole bumped and leaned against the bar beside me. "Hey."

I"d had a bit of a crush on Cole Davies for a long time, but this was the closest I"d ever been to him, as far as I knew. He"d never seemed particularly interested in me.

"Hey," I said. "Toby is right, you played so well. It seemed like you were everywhere. That final goal Cruz got in with your assist, I wouldn"t have believed it if I hadn"t seen it with my own eyes." They"d moved so fast I barely saw the puck before it was slamming into the net.

"Toby is always right when it comes to hockey," Toby said with a chuckle.

"Does Toby always talk about himself in third person?" I teased. Now I was picturing him naked, telling an enraptured Internet audience about Cole"s assist.

"Sometimes," Toby said. "Only when he"s especially impressed." He gave Cole a piercing look.

I glanced between them. Cole"s cheeks were slightly pink. The vibes they were giving off suggested they were into each other. That would explain why Cole wasn"t interested in me. Only…now he was looking at both of us the same way.

His Adam"s apple bobbed and he glanced down at the worn hardwood floor. After a few beats, he glanced back. "Just doing my job."

It never occurred to me before that he might just be shy. So many of the guys on the team were outgoing, their personalities so strong they overshadowed the people around them. It was easy to assume they were all like that, but evidently that assumption was wrong.

"You do it well." I put a hand on his bicep. His muscle was rock hard under my palm.

"Thanks," he said awkwardly. "I appreciate that."

"I appreciate the way you stuck up for me the other week," I said. "With Elliott and Saxon. It was…kinda hot."

He looked at my hand resting on his arm. "My brother gets out of hand sometimes. Elliott too. Someone has to keep an eye on them."

"Shouldn"t have to be you, bro," Toby said. "You"re here to have fun too."

"Yeah." Cole didn"t look like he entirely believed that. "Sometimes it"s easier to stop shit before it happens, you know? Those two like to think they can do whatever they want to whoever they want. Sooner or later, they"re going to overstep, hard."

"It"s not your responsibility to pick up the pieces," Toby said. "They"re grown men. You gotta live your life."

"Toby is right again," I said.

"Some kinda record," Toby said jokingly. He downed the rest of his drink and placed his empty glass back on the bar. "Come on, let"s dance."

He gestured toward the crowded dance floor in front of the live band that was rocking out to the side of the pub.

Cole looked like he might argue, but Toby grabbed both of our hands and pulled us through the crowds.

We squeezed into a space on the edge of the dance floor. Toby stood in front of me and manoeuvred Cole to stand behind me. Toby grabbed my arms and draped them over his shoulders, pulling me close until my body was pressed against his.

Cole placed his hands on my shoulders, his pelvis lightly touching my ass.

The warmth from both of their bodies penetrated my clothes all the way down, past my skin.

The band started to play a slow song, the guitar a smooth accompaniment to the keyboard and the lead singer's husky vocals. If the guys didn"t get me going, the music would.

In near perfect unison, we swayed, bodies grinding against each other. I was quickly breathless.

Holy shit. I"d never been in the middle of a hockey god sandwich, but I liked it. I went on swaying, my ass rubbing against Cole"s cock until he was hard. Both of their erections pressed into me. My panties were completely and utterly ruined.

"Maybe we should get out of here." Toby brushed hair off my neck and leaned in to kiss my throat. He lifted his face, looked towards Cole and said, "All of us."

Was he suggesting what I thought he was suggesting? Because if he was, I was here for it.

"If Marley wants to." Cole stroked his thumb across the side of my neck, making me hotter still.

"Marley wants to," I said. "Very much."

"Let"s go then." Toby gripped my hand and Cole took the other. Linked like that, we made our way to the door and out into the cool of the night.

"My place isn"t far," Toby said.

Cole stopped to glance back at the pub, an uneasy expression on his face again.

"Let your brother deal with his own shit," Toby told him. "Let"s go and have some fun." Without waiting for further argument, he led us to a small apartment building a block from the pub.

I admit to doing a quick glance back of my own. Oliver hadn"t been at the pub or the game tonight, it was his turn to be on call at the hospital. I missed his presence, if not having to dodge Cat.

I pulled out my phone and sent off a quick text, explaining where I was going and why. I had his blessing, but I wanted him to know exactly what was happening. Going around behind my friends' backs was bad enough without feeling like I was doing anything behind his.

He responded a minute or two later with a text saying,

Have fun. Those boys better give you plenty of orgasms.

I smiled and replied with,

They will.

I hoped.

Both of them pressed close to me, we travelled up the elevator to the third floor. Toby unlocked his door and waved us both inside. The door barely closed behind us before his mouth was on mine, and Cole"s hands were sliding up the back of my Ghouls jersey.

"Are you sure we"re not going too fast?" I asked. Toby and I had agreed not to, but now, in the heat of the moment, it would be easy to get carried away.

"I"m sure," Toby said between kisses. "If you are?"

"I"m sure," I said. I glanced over my shoulder to Cole.

"As long as you both want me here, then I"m sure too," Cole said. He looked pained, like if we stopped now, he"d have to get himself off in the elevator on the way down to the ground floor.

"We do," I said. Not just because I didn"t want him to have to do that.

I turned to face him and pressed my palms to his rock hard chest. I looked him right in the eyes and tangled my fingers in his shirt. I pulled him down so I could kiss his mouth.

He tasted like bourbon and ginger. Masculine and spicy, but sweet at the same time. His lips were the perfect, soft contrast to the rasp of his stubble against my skin.

I tugged up the front of his shirt and pulled it off over his head. He let it drop to the floor.

"Holy shit, you"re beautiful," I said. His body was all firm muscle, perfect dips and planes, with scars here and there.

His cheeks went pink. "I don"t know about that."

"I do," Toby said. "You"re fucking gorgeous. Both of you." He turned me back around to face him and kissed me while helping me out of my jersey.

Cole unhooked my bra and pushed the straps down my arms before cupping my breasts from behind and palming my nipples.

Toby kissed my mouth and down my cheek to my neck before breaking off and pressing his mouth to Cole"s.

I leaned my head back slightly to watch them make out with each other. Holy puck that was hot.

Toby slid his tongue across Cole"s lower lip and inside his mouth. He thrust it in and out a few times like he was fucking his mouth.

Cole moved one of his hands from my breast down to Toby"s erection, which looked as though it was trying to split the seam of his jeans.

Toby undid his pants and pushed them and his boxers down, letting his cock free. He gently took Cole"s hand and wrapped it around his length.

Cole"s blush deepened, but he pumped Toby a handful of times before swallowing hard and sinking to his knees. He looked up at Toby and me, then slowly licked the head of Toby"s cock.

"Oh, yeah," Toby breathed. "That feels good."

Cole closed his mouth around Toby"s tip and started to suck. His lips made a soft, wet sound as his lips worked, sliding back and forth with each bob of his head.

I shimmied out of the rest of my clothes and knelt down beside Cole. I worked his jeans down and curled my fingers around his cock. He was hard as a rock, a thick vein throbbing at the base of his length.

He groaned and thrust into my hand. He pulled his mouth off Toby. His voice husky, he said, "I want to be inside you."

I guided him off Toby and replaced him, the goalie"s cock in my mouth while I got on all fours. Cole scooted around behind me, kissed my ass cheek a couple of times before pushing his fingers deep into my pussy.

"You"re so wet already." He sounded amazed and surprised.

I hummed my agreement and went on sucking and licking, teasing Toby with my lips and tongue.

Cole slid out his fingers, positioned his cock and thrust into me. With one stroke, he was fully seated inside me. He was still for a while before he started to thrust. He pressed a hand between us, rubbing my clit in time with his movements.

I looked up to see Toby watching us, his lips slightly apart.

"That"s fucking hot," he said. "Fuck her harder."

Cole did. Pounding into me with more and more force, grunting each time. His fingers were relentless on my clit, pinching and rolling until all I could do was come, screaming around Toby"s cock.

Cole followed a moment later, his hips stilling as he came inside me.

"Just like that." Toby grabbed my hair and pulled my mouth off his cock. He waited until Cole slid out of me before turning me around, kneeling behind me and slamming his cock into my pussy.

He groaned, long and low. "Fucking hell, that"s good." He snaked an arm around the back of Cole"s neck, pulling him in for a kiss at the same time as he was fucking me.

Between the sensation of him sliding in and out of me, and the wet sound of their kisses, I couldn"t stop myself from coming again. And again.

The third time I came, Toby came with me, thrusting frantically before adding his cum to Cole"s inside my body. I felt so full I'd probably leak for days, but I loved every minute of it. I"d never been with two smoking hot guys before. The fact they were into each other too added to the heat level by approximately a billion percent.

Toby sagged over me, puffing lightly. "Let"s get cleaned up. Then it's time for round two."