Maggie Milena is a professional matchmaker who can match up anyone but herself. Noah Riley can't manage to get a second date…with anyone. When Maggie applies her trademark skills, the results do not go as planned. And now both of their lives are in jeopardy.

No one looking at the gorgeous Noah Riley would ever believe he's the embodiment of love's misfortune, plagued by disastrous first dates and an uncanny/a confounding inability to secure a second. He seeks a change of fate by enlisting the matchmaking expertise of Maggie, his old high school crush who still secretly makes his heart pound.

But destiny takes a cruel twist when an evening orchestrated by Maggie ends in the mysterious disappearance of Noah's date, leaving him in the crosshairs of suspicion. As they race against the clock to exonerate Noah and unearth the missing woman's whereabouts, danger escalates, testing their resolve and rekindling a love that can no longer be denied.