24. The Prize

Chapter 24

The Prize

Libby

T wo hours later, we were back at the condo. I had a blast at the arcade and loved watching Leo slowly come out of his shell around me and Ethan. The competitiveness between the two of them was intense, and I couldn’t help but think about how that might look in the bedroom.

I’d never thought about sex so much in my life but found it harder and harder not to constantly have it on my mind anytime I was around the two of them.

“I am beat.” Ethan hopped over the back of the couch, plopping onto it. “Time for my prize.”

“Right now?” I pushed open the lid of my tumbler and moved into the living room to join him on the couch.

“Not so fast. Give me that and go stand in front of the TV.” Ethan grabbed my cup after I took a drink.

“Why?” I craned my neck to look down the hall. Leo had disappeared to his room but hadn’t come back yet.

“Because I’m in charge and I want to look at you.” Ethan took a sip of my water before putting it on the coffee table and pushing the table out of the way.

I blushed as I moved where he asked. “You look at me all the time, Ethan.”

“Get undressed.” He leaned back on the couch, his arms spread across the back like he was some kind of royalty. “Everything off.”

I bit my lip, and we stared at each other. When he didn’t say anything, I sighed and started to take off my clothes. It was different getting undressed so far away from him where he could see everything.

“I got what you requested, sir.” Leo snorted a laugh as he came back into the room and placed a bottle of lube and a strip of condoms on the coffee table.

“Sir? I like that. Thanks for the idea. You’ll both call me sir.”

It was my turn to snort, and Ethan raised his brows. “Don’t forget who’s in charge tonight, Elizabeth.” He so rarely called me by my full name, and I was glad he didn’t because I felt it between my legs in the same way I did when Leo called me it.

“Yes, sir.” I saluted him with a smirk. “Now what? Am I just going to stand here and freeze my tits off?”

“No. Leo is going to join you so I can see my prizes.” Smug Ethan was very sexy, and I squeezed my thighs together.

“You’re ridiculous.” Leo stripped out of his clothes, coming to stand next to me. He was already hard, and I was tempted to drop to my knees and take him in my mouth, not only to see his reaction, but to see what Ethan would do.

His gaze was intense, his eyes roving over us like we were his personal playthings. I couldn’t deny the thrill that ran through me at the thought.

“On your knees,” Ethan commanded, his voice husky with desire. “Both of you.”

Leo and I exchanged a glance before we slowly sank to our knees. The area rug was soft beneath me, but the position felt anything but comfortable. It was submissive, but excitement pulsed through me.

Ethan stood up, towering over us as he began to unbutton his jeans. “Crawl to me.” His voice was laced with a dominance I hadn’t heard before, and I found myself complying, my hands and knees pressing into the carpet as I moved toward him.

Leo followed suit, his breath hitching slightly as we made our way to Ethan. Being at Ethan’s beck and call must have been driving him crazy, but I heard no complaints.

When we reached him, Ethan had his pants down, his cock already hard and straining against his boxer briefs. He pushed them down, revealing himself fully to us. I licked my lips, my mouth suddenly dry as I stared at him.

He wrapped his hand around the base of his cock. “I want you both to suck me. Together.”

I looked up at Ethan, my eyes wide with surprise. Beside me, Leo let out a soft groan, his cock twitching at the command. I turned to him, our eyes meeting briefly. He was nervous, and I couldn’t blame him; I knew this was Leo’s first time giving a blow job.

We both leaned in, our mouths meeting around the sides of Ethan’s cock. It was awkward as we tried to find a rhythm.

“That’s it,” Ethan groaned, his hand fisting in my hair. “Show Leo how to take me deep, Lib. Fuck, yes, just like that. Now his turn.”

Leo looked unsure as I popped off Ethan’s cock. “You’ve got this. Take him as far as you can.” I kissed him, our tongues tangling as he deepened the kiss.

“I could watch you two make out all night.” Ethan stroked his cock while he waited for Leo.

Finally, Leo pulled away and hesitated only a second before taking Ethan all the way to the back of his throat. It was impressive to say the least, and I reached down between my legs to play with my clit.

“Are you nice and wet? Let me see.” Ethan’s hand threaded through Leo’s hair, and he groaned as I showed him my wet fingers.

He grabbed my wrist and bent down, bringing my fingers to his mouth and sucking them. My body lit up and I let out a whimper. This was beyond the sexiest thing I’d ever experienced.

“I need both of your mouths on me again.”

We followed his instructions, Leo and I returning to sucking him from the sides. I could feel Leo’s mouth against mine, his tongue sliding against Ethan’s cock in a way that sent heat pooling between my legs.

Ethan grabbed my hair, his grip tightening. “You both look so fucking hot like this. On your knees, sucking my cock. Fuck, I could come from just the sight of it.”

I moaned around him, my body responding to his words. My nipples were hard, and my clit throbbed. Beside me, Leo’s breath was coming in ragged pants.

Ethan suddenly pulled back, his cock slipping from between our mouths. “I want you both to watch me.”

He pulled off his shirt and kicked off his pants and boxers that had pooled at his ankles. When he reached for the lube on the coffee table and propped one of his legs on it, I realized what he was about to do. My eyes widened as he poured a generous amount on his fingers.

Ethan spread his legs wider, his fingers moving to his ass. I watched, mesmerized, as he began to circle his hole, his breath hitching slightly as he pressed a finger inside.

“Fuck,” he groaned, his eyes fluttering closed. “I want you to watch me prepare myself, Libby. I want you to see what I’m going to let Leo do to me.”

I swallowed hard, my body aching with need as I watched Ethan finger himself. It was erotic and intimate, and I couldn’t look away. Beside me, Leo let out a soft groan, his hand wrapping around his cock as he watched Ethan.

Ethan added another finger, his breath coming in ragged pants as he stretched himself. His eyes met mine. “Lie down and let Leo make sure you’re nice and ready for me.”

Leo grabbed a pillow for my head and then another for under my hips. I lay back, spreading my legs for Ethan to see a full view of everything. I felt exposed but sexy as hell as both men stared at me with hunger in their eyes.

Leo knelt at my side, his fingers trailing up my inner thighs. His fingers reached my center, and he let out a soft groan as he felt how wet I was. “Fuck, Elizabeth. You are so wet and hot.”

He began to circle my clit, and I arched my back, a soft moan escaping my lips as waves of pleasure washed over me. His fingers moved lower, teasing my entrance before slowly pushing inside.

I gasped, my nails digging into the carpet as he began to move his fingers in and out, his thumb circling my clit in a rhythm that had my body writhing beneath him.

Ethan watched us, his eyes dark with desire as he continued to prepare himself. His cock was hard and ready, and I couldn’t wait to feel him inside me. I was lost in the sensations Leo was creating, his fingers hitting all the right spots as he brought me closer and closer to the edge. Right as I was about to tumble over, Ethan’s voice cut through the haze of pleasure.

“That’s enough, Leo. I want her to come around my cock.” Ethan removed his fingers, putting his foot down before tossing Leo two condoms. “Put one on me, then put one on yourself.”

Leo’s hands trembled slightly as he tore open the condom wrapper and rolled it onto Ethan’s cock. He then quickly put one on himself, his eyes never leaving Ethan’s.

Ethan positioned himself between my legs, his hands gripping my hips as he lined himself up with my entrance. He looked down at me, his eyes filled with a mix of lust and tenderness. “You ready, Lib?”

I nodded, my voice barely a whisper. “Yes.”

He pushed into me, his cock filling me inch by inch. I let out a soft moan, my body stretching to accommodate him. He felt amazing, and I wrapped my legs around his waist, pulling him deeper.

Ethan leaned down, his lips capturing mine in a passionate kiss as he began to move inside me. Behind him, Leo positioned himself, his hands gripping Ethan’s hips.

Ethan stilled inside me and his breath hitched as Leo pushed into him.

A mixture of pleasure and pain crossed Ethan’s face, his eyes closing as he adjusted to the sensation. I’d never had anal before, but I was sure it would happen eventually.

I could tell the instant Ethan was ready for Leo because his eyes popped open, and he was practically growling. “Fuck me, Leo.”

Leo began to move and so did Ethan, their thrusts syncing as they found their rhythm. The sight of them together and the feeling of Ethan inside me was all too much. My body trembled as I got closer to pure bliss.

Ethan’s lips found mine again, his kiss swallowing my moans as we moved together. His thrusts became more urgent, his grip on my hips tightening as he chased his own release.

“Fuck, Libby,” he groaned against my lips. “You feel so fucking good.”

My body was on fire, and I could only whimper in response. Ethan’s cock felt like it was pulsing inside me, and with the position he was in, I wasn’t even going to need to touch my clit to come.

One of Leo’s hands gripped Ethan’s shoulder, the other firmly on his hip. His breath was ragged as he fucked Ethan with abandon.

“Come with me.” He groaned into my neck, his voice strained with effort. “Let go, baby.”

“Ethan!” I cried out, my body shaking as my orgasm crashed through me, deep and hard.

“Fuck! Fuck! Fuck!” Ethan chanted with each erratic thrust, following me down into a pool of pleasure.

Behind him, Leo let out a low groan, his body shuddering as he came. I couldn’t see his face since he had it buried against the back of Ethan’s neck.

Leo collapsed onto the rug next to me, taking my hand and bringing it to his heaving chest. Ethan rolled off me, his arm draping over my stomach as he cuddled into my side.

We lay there in silence, none of us able to speak as the complications and uncertainties of our relationship faded away.