14. Cole

Chapter fourteen

Cole

Sitting up, I stare at the tattoo hidden between my three French hens. “When did I get this?” I’m not sure how long it’s been there. I hardly inspect my thighs on a daily basis.

“Maybe when we arrived? Couldn’t have been before that, since the distance limit wouldn’t have allowed it,” Jasper suggests, thumb idly stroking over the tattoo.

“I didn’t feel the moment I got mine either,” Natalie explains. “I just noticed it when I was sitting on the couch in the middle of a meeting on the island. When I noticed it, it kind of triggered everyone into searching their bodies for their own markings. Those with markings in the same spot are bonded.”

“It makes sense for you two to have it, since you were there at the same time. But why me? Why now?” I’m too nervous to get excited, scared it might be a mistake of some sort, but a tiny part of me is holding on to the hope that I’m just as much a part of this inexplicable connection and bond now.

“Let me call Bertie and ask him. Maybe he knows,” Jasper says in what I’m assuming is a reassuring smile, but his pure joy is hard to hide when his eyes are shining so brightly.

Not waiting a moment longer, Jasper gets up and searches for his phone among his luggage, and dials Adelbert. I almost want to ask him to put the call on speaker, but I know Adelbert would not like that much, so I content myself with waiting patiently for him to finish—my heart beating erratically all the while.

Seemingly aware that I need to be distracted, Natalie straddles my hips and my hands automatically settle on her delicious thighs. I stroke up and down her skin, watching my fingers glide over the band of tattoos circling her thigh, and over our shared tattoo.

My fingers get greedy, and I start kneading her thighs, sinking my fingers into her flesh, and wondering how she likes to be gripped. Her subtle rocking has my cock growing hard, and a smirk spreads across her lips when she feels it against the thin layer of her tiny sleep shorts.

Natalie places a finger against my lips, letting me know I have to be quiet while Jasper is on the phone. I give her a nod, then she braces her hands on my chest and grinds down hard on my cock.

My stomach muscles contract and I grit my teeth against the sensation. I’ve already come twice and I don’t know if I’m able to come again, but Natalie looks set on trying to get me there.

Still on the phone, Jasper comes to stand at the side of the bed and stares down at us with uncontained desire. He rubs his cock through his loose pajama pants, but the look he gives me turns devilish. Pulling his cock free, he holds it in front of my face and mouths, “Lick.”

Not knowing when these two teamed up, I open my mouth obediently and lick a delicious drop of gingerbread cum from Jasper’s slit. He rolls his lips between his teeth to keep a sound from escaping, but his eyes roll back in his head as I shower his cock with attention.

Natalie rocks faster and faster, my fingers digging into her ass to help her set a rhythm, but there’s no controlling her right now. Not her, and not Jasper.

My heartbeat ratchets up, slamming against my chest, drumming through my whole body, until I’m a big pile of need. I’m not above begging at this stage, but I’m trying to keep from making any sounds.

I want to shove Natalie’s shorts aside and plunge into her, but not like this. When I take her cunt, I want to hear her scream.

Jasper keeps his answers short, Adelbert seemingly doing the heavy lifting in the conversation, and I double down on his cock. Making eye contact with him, I spit on his cock and wrap my hand around him and squeeze. His breath stutters and mine becomes shallow.

“Yes, thank you. I’ll tell them. We’ll chat tomorrow on the video call then. Bye,” Jasper says into the phone and then he’s flinging it across the room with a wild look in his eyes.

“Look how well you’re sucking this cock, Cole. But telling by the veins bulging in your neck, you need to come real soon. Doesn’t he look sweet like this, Natalie? Naked beneath us while we toy with him?”

“So good,” Natalie says with a bright sheen on her cheeks. “Cole is such a good boy for us,” she teases.

Not able to stand this any longer, I flip her onto her back. “Good boy, you say? No, no, no, little vixen. You’re barking up the wrong tree. I’m going to stuff this cunt with my cock right now and teach you a lesson while you try to suck Jasper’s cum straight from his cock. Okay?”

Jasper looks to Natalie with a question in his eyes that he gives voice to. “Are you too sore? We can stop if you need.”

“I don’t know how or when it happened, but I’m already good to go. Give me all your cum. I’m tested and on birth control too.”

“Us too,” I say, and rip her shorts down her legs. Seeing the glistening arousal dripping from her, I know she’s ready for me. I drape her legs around me and in one single thrust, plunge my cock into her warm cunt.

Natalie’s back bows off the bed and she screams with pleasure, but I’m not done. I thrust hard and fast, and when she’s squeezing around my cock like she’s about to explode, I stop.

“No! Whyyyy? I was so close,” Natalie whines, trying to thrust herself onto my cock.

“Who’s a good boy, now?” I taunt. “Up.” I pull out of her and position her onto her hands and knees. “Give Jasper your mouth.”

Jasper notes my mood and positions himself in front of her, guiding his cock to her mouth, but not pushing in. Natalie’s desire to satisfy him pleases me immensely as she lavishes his cock with attention.

On my knees behind her, I pull her cheeks apart. “Tell me, Natalie, how do you feel about anal?”

“Love it,” she mumbles, mouth not lifting off Jasper’s cock.

“Good. Soon, you’ll take me in this tight little hole, while Jasper takes your cunt with his thick cock. You’ll be such a good girl taking us both. That’s what you really want to be, isn’t it?” I tease, knowing it’ll rile her up and that she gets off on this talk as much as we do.

Before she can respond, I thrust back into her dripping cunt and fuck her hard. Jasper holds her steady as my thrusts move her too much to keep her mouth on his cock. When her walls squeeze around me again, I pause.

“No. Not again,” she sobs and lowers herself onto her elbows. There’s no real hurt in her voice, more annoyance.

“I thought you liked edging?” I say and thrust again lightly, caressing her back and appreciating the view from this angle.

“I do,” Natalie admits and tightens her muscles around my cock.

“Jasper, come lie down here.” I point to the middle of the bed and slowly pull out of Natalie. I see him hesitate and I know he thinks he’s too big, that maybe he’ll hurt her, but I know without a shadow of a doubt that Natalie can take him.

Every instinct within me, the very essence of my being can admit that somehow the three of us were made for each other. That we fit together in a way that just makes sense. Tattoo or no tattoo, something about us feels right.

I soften my voice, “She can take you, I’m sure of it. Now, hang your head off the side of the bed so I can fuck your throat. Natalie’s going to work herself down on your cock at her own pace. Everyone in?”

Natalie sits back on her haunches and looks at Jasper. Pointing to his cock, she says with surety, “That beast will be conquered tonight. I’m so horny and so wet right now, I can take anything. Jasper, you just lie down and I’ll do all the work.”

Seemingly satisfied with that, Jasper lies back, cock jutting proudly into the air. He really is enormous. And so, so perfect.

Natalie crawls up his thighs and slowly rubs her wet pussy all over him. “I’ve never been as wet as I’ve been since I met you two. I don’t know what it is, but I’m constantly dripping.”

I note the muscles in Jasper’s throat bob on a swallow. Why he’s suddenly nervous, I’m not sure, but he quickly covers it with, “Maybe that pussy was made to take this cock. The only way to take me was if you were slick with arousal. And aren’t you, Natalie? You’re slick for us with your sugar cookie flavor.”

“Fuck, yes, I am,” Natalie says and notches him at her entrance. Completely entranced, I watch her slowly lower herself down on his cock in incremental movements. Her eyes flutter closed and her chest moves up and down on shallow breaths.

“That’s it, Natalie. You’re doing so well. Look how beautiful you are stretched around that fat cock. Good girl. Good girl,” I croon, leaning forward to stroke her face.

“So. Full. Good. Cock. Perfect,” Natalie pants with a dazed smile. Sweat dots her brow as she lifts up an inch before sinking down two more.

“Natalie, you feel so good. This cunt is so tight and warm and wet. You were made for my cock,” Jasper grits out. His white-knuckled grip on the blanket is trembling, his pulse erratic in his throat as he watches Natalie’s progress.

I lift his hands and place them on Natalie’s tits and he starts playing with them, distracting both of them while she makes her way to the hilt.

When her hips are finally flush with his, I place a hand on her lower stomach, the outline of Jasper’s cock causing it to bulge. “Look at this. So full. You’re gorgeous, the both of you. So good together.”

Natalie pants, her eyes wild but happy and a victorious smile stretches her lips until her whole face transforms into satisfaction. “I knew you’d fit,” she says and winks at Jasper.

Something odd happens in my chest and travels all the way to my toes. In this moment, I know that I’m already falling for Natalie as deeply as I’ve fallen for Jasper. A feeling of determination settles deep in my gut as I decide that I will do anything I can to keep them. I will court not only my krampus, but my human too. Make them want to stay and take on life together with me.

Jasper’s fingers settle around Natalie’s waist, a look of pure awe in his eyes as he says, “You really are made for me. Us .”

“She is,” I whisper, still amazed at how seamlessly we’ve come together and how hard I’ll fight for our happy ending.

“Cole, take his throat. I’m owning this cock tonight,” Natalie directs like the boss she is, lifting off Jasper’s cock again before dropping back down. Hard. Jasper gasps and his hands settle around her waist.

I bend forward and give Natalie a sloppy kiss, then move to stand at Jasper’s head, stepping carefully between his horns. Tapping his cheek, I say, “Open wide. You know the drill. Tap my leg if you need a breath.”

Together, Natalie and I work Jasper over. She rides Jasper’s cock like a cowgirl set on winning a rodeo. And Jasper, being the prized bull, gives her as much as he can while I’m holding his throat captive.

Natalie moans, her tits bouncing with her movements. Her cheeks are flushed, her head thrown back in ecstasy but her gaze stays on Jasper’s lips around my cock, flicking to my face every now and then.

Together, our bodies create a symphony of carnal sounds as we get lost to speech and give over to sensations.

Noting the clench of Jasper’s abs, the cadence of Natalie’s breath and the telltale signs of an orgasm building in the base of my spine, I find the words to push us into the abyss of pleasure together.

“Come for me.”

I pull out of Jasper’s mouth and spray my cum across his chest just as Natalie starts to go limp with her release. Jasper sits up and gathers her into his arms, rolling them so she’s on her back. He pulls out a little and wraps his hand around his inflated knot as he pumps her full of cum.

Finally sated, Jasper rolls over and lies on his back, cock slowly going soft as his breathing starts to even out.

I walk around the bed, watching streams of Jasper’s delicious cum dripping from Natalie’s cunt. As if my brain is unable to control my body, only instinct dictating my moves, I surge forward and start licking Jasper and Natalie’s combined releases from between her swollen pussy lips. It’s the most exquisite thing I’ve ever tasted. The perfect mix of sugar and spice.

Natalie’s final orgasm of the night is a tiny shudder running through her body and a sigh of contentment escaping from her lips.

I look down at the two beings who couldn’t be more different, but somehow hold my heart equally. Something magical occurred tonight, bound us together in some way. I’m not sure what the consequences are yet, but I’m all in with both of them.

Now, just to convince them to pick me too.