Chapter 4

Nicholas

Lilly's begging nearly brought me to my knees, but I had to stay strong. She knew I wanted her mouth around my cock, but she chose to be uncooperative instead. I loved getting to punish her, though, so I wasn't upset about her display of defiance.

"On the bed, head off the side," I ordered her.

I released her hair so she could do as I said, and she moved to obey without a word. It took everything in my power not to tear off her clothes and make her scream as she came on my cock, but I managed to hold it together.

That was, until the back of her head bounced on the side of the bed, mouth open wide just for me.

A feral growl vibrated in my throat as I stroked my cock, taking slow steps in her direction.

"Are you going to take your punishment like a good little whore?" I rubbed the tip of my cock against her lips. She opened her mouth a little wider, and I thrusted into her mouth, hitting the back of her throat.

Her body immediately stiffened, and her hands clenched the sheets beside her, but she stayed calm and breathed through her nose like we'd told her to do many times before. She was such a good girl, taking so much of me in her mouth.

I pulled my cock back and gave her a moment to breathe before thrusting back in. This time, I held myself at the back of her throat for a few seconds, feeling her try to swallow around me. I pulled out again then pushed back in until she was gagging. Spit ran down her face as her body started to fight me.

"Be a good girl for me, Lilly. Take your punishment like the slut you are," I taunted. "You know you earned it."

She pressed her thighs together and tilted her hips, loving every degrading word.

"My turn," my twin said from behind me.

I pulled out of Lilly's mouth, but before she could recover from my assault, Aiden slid himself in, taking my place. He handed me the rope he'd grabbed from the drawer as he fucked our girl's face, making her gag on his cock as well.

I got onto the bed, throwing one leg over Lilly's body so I could straddle her. I took the rope and tied her wrists together in front of her. She tried to move to see what I was doing, but Aiden's cock down her throat kept her in place.

"Such a good girl, little one," my brother praised her.

I felt her body tighten under me. Our girl loved being praised just as much as she liked being degraded. She was our perfect match.

I slid my hand under the waistband of her shorts, stopping when I didn't find any panties.

"You filthy fucking girl. No panties? You were hoping to get fucked, weren't you?" I asked her. "You've probably been thinking of having your holes filled all morning, haven't you?"

She whined, unable to speak with her mouth so full, and tried to grind up against my fingers. I pushed her hips down with my free hand before plunging my fingers into her wet cunt.

She immediately moaned, which made Aiden moan with her. I found her clit with my free hand, pinching it at first, then rubbing it gently. Her moans and gags made my cock twitch with need. I wanted back inside her.

I yanked my hands away from her pussy, and she let out a frustrated sound. A chuckle left my throat as I removed her shorts, her enthusiastic hip wiggling making the task even easier.

I grabbed her knees and positioned her legs exactly where I wanted them.

"Stay," I instructed her.

Her legs stayed up in the air, bent at the knees, while I took my clothes off and then lined myself up with her soaking entrance. When I slammed my cock balls deep into her, not wasting any time getting inside her, Aiden pulled out of her mouth.

"Fuck!" she cried out as her tight walls stretched to accommodate me.

Aiden pulled her restrained wrists up and around my neck, and I sat up so she was sitting on my thighs, my cock still deep inside her.

I continued to thrust into her on my knees and watched as her eyes rolled back into her head. It was the sexiest thing I'd ever seen. I loved knowing and seeing how good I made her feel. Her eyes were pinched shut as I pumped into her, giving her nothing but pure bliss.

"Kiss me," she demanded through her heavy breathing.

I happily obliged, consuming her mouth with my own. Her lips parted, giving way to my tongue slipping inside to unite with hers. Hail Satan, she tasted so good.

She pulled away. "I need to—"

"Come for me, baby," I whispered in her ear before biting down on her earlobe.

Her back arched, forcing her onto me further as her muscles clenched around my cock. Her moans filled the room as I thrusted through her orgasm, her pleasure sweet music to my ears.

Aiden climbed onto the bed behind Lilly on his knees.

Lilly was still shaking through the after-waves of her first orgasm when I unhooked her arms from around my neck and passed her to Aiden. While she had gained a little much-needed weight from being cared for here in Hell, she was still light as a feather to us.

Aiden hooked her arms around his neck and used his grip on her ass to slide her down onto him. Her legs wrapped around his waist. "I believe it's your turn to claim that ass, brother," he said with a chuckle.

Lilly's body tensed up at his words, but she didn't refuse. I knew being fucked in the ass still freaked her out a little, but we all knew she loved it. She'd proven that to us the day we used her in front of that worthless human. Austin, the man— boy, really—who'd tried to take advantage of her in our portal, on our altar. He'd gotten what he deserved, though, and none of us, including Lilly, had a single regret about how he met his demise.

My cock was still slick with remnants of her orgasm, so once Aiden settled into a pace with her, moan after moan being drawn from her lips, I lined up with her tight asshole and pressed the first inch of my cock inside.

Her ass contracted, trying to push me out, but I slowly pushed in another inch. She looked up at the ceiling as she whimpered.

I leaned in so I could whisper in her ear. "Relax for me, Lilly. Let me in. I'll make you feel so good, I promise. I always do." I continued to inch my cock into her ass until I was fully sheathed inside her body. I groaned at the pressure surrounding my cock, the feeling of sliding in and out of such a tight hole almost too much to bear.

All three of us moved in sync, the sounds of our satisfaction bouncing off the walls.

"Does our little whore like having her ass full?" I asked her, licking up the back of her ear as I reached around the front of her to pinch one of her nipples.

"Fuck!" She threw her head back onto my shoulder.

She was so beautiful like this, panting, sweating, and moaning, her eyes closed as she let us control her body.

Aiden kissed her neck then bit down hard enough to make her cry out. "Nicholas asked you a question, little one."

"Yes," she finally answered me.

"Yes, what?" I pushed.

She groaned, trying her hardest to focus on something other than the two cocks she was filled with. I knew it was hard for her to form words when we had her this worked up, but I loved hearing her talk. Her cute voice was so breathy and high-pitched. It made my cock swell just hearing her say dirty things back to us.

"I like having my ass full," she slurred thanks to the impending orgasm we were fucking her into.

I continued to roll her nipple around in my fingers then squeezed hard. Our girl's body shook, and she tried to pull her arms in, but she was powerless to do anything except enjoy having her holes full of our cocks and scream our names.

"Just like that," Aiden cooed at her, still scattering kisses on her neck. "I love how your pussy grabs my cock when you come, like it doesn't want to let go. Hail Satan, I could fuck this pussy all day."

His words were fuel on the fire, and while she had been coming down from her orgasm, her body tightened again.

"I'm coming again!" she yelled, and her entire body went stiff. "Make it stop!" She was holding her breath, mouth open, like she wanted to make some sort of sound, but it wouldn't come out.

Aiden continued to kiss her neck, and I pinched her nipple as I sucked on her earlobe.

"You're doing so good," I told her. "This is exactly what you wanted, isn't it? To be fucked by me and my brother until you can't take anymore?"

While she couldn't speak, she did manage to bob her head.

"That's what I thought. Such a filthy slut for our cocks." She shuddered at my words. "Come for us one more time, baby. I want to feel your ass milk my cock as I fill you with my cum."

She mewled at the thought of enduring another orgasm, but she didn't have much of a choice as her body threw her overboard anyway. I hissed when her muscles contracted around me, squeezing so tight, I couldn't hold back any longer. My balls drew up, and my thighs tensed so hard, I was locked in place. I closed my eyes, white-hot pleasure exploding behind my lids. Aiden groaned, his pace stuttering a bit. Our hot cum shot into her, making the wet noises of our thrusts louder with all the liquid filling her holes as we continued to fuck her until her body relaxed.

I pulled out of her first, her whimpers already making me semi-hard again. When Aiden pulled out of her, he untied her arms and laid her down in the bed. I tucked one arm under her knees and the other under her shoulders and took her to the bathroom.

"I don't know how much longer I can keep up with you two," she joked as I placed her on her feet on the shower floor. She braced herself against me, legs still wobbly, as she let the hot water hit her back.

"Sorry." I chuckled. "You're just too sexy, baby. We can't help it." I kissed her neck, and she looked up to the showerhead, giving me more room to work with. I pulled her soft, thin skin into my mouth and sucked until I was sure I'd left a mark.

"Nicholas…" she murmured.

Aiden joined us in the shower. "I didn't know you two were continuing the fun in here," he teased as he licked his lips, looking at our girl like she was his breakfast. "I would've gotten in here faster."

Lilly shook her head. "I'm tapping out. My poor vagina needs a break."

Aiden clicked his tongue and leaned in for her. "Are you sure about that?" He took a small step toward her, like a wild animal stalking their prey.

She laughed nervously as she stepped away from him, bumping right into me. Aiden gave me a look, and I knew what he wanted me to do.

I grabbed Lilly's right leg, wrapping my hand around her inner thigh, and pulled it up so she was only on one foot. With my other arm, I held her arms across her belly.

"Please," she begged us. "Don't. I'm so tired."

I pressed my lips against the shell of her ear. "You can rest once we're done with you. This body is ours, Lilly. We can use it as much as we'd like, and right now, my brother wants to worship that sweet cunt. So be quiet and enjoy what we give you."

She whimpered, pulling just barely against me, hardly resisting.

Aiden bent down, his eyes on her pretty, pink pussy. He gave Lilly one lustful grin before diving in with his tongue. He devoured her until she was shaking and screaming through another orgasm. My grip on her body was the only thing keeping her from falling to the tile floor as he had his way with her body.

My brother helped me clean her up once he was finished, and then I took her to bed and tucked her in. She was snoring softly before I had the covers over her shoulders.

I turned my head when I heard the sound of someone clearing their throat. Keir was leaning against the doorframe, an odd look on his face. Could someone be jealous and disappointed at the same time? Because that's precisely how he looked.

"She's never going to have the energy to train or complete the trials with you two using her up like this," he scolded.

"You're just jealous," Aiden remarked. "You don't have to be, though."

Keir rolled his eyes. "I am not jealous. I'm just concerned, but apparently, neither of you two are. Do you realize what's at stake here?" He stood straight, his finger pointing at the woman sleeping soundly in our bed.

I knew what was at stake here: Lilly's life. Our offering. Keir's destined love.

"We'll ease up on her," I offered as a white flag. "Focus more on training." I heard Aiden scoff, and I turned to him. "Lilly can go back to being our little offering when she successfully completes the trials." I gave him a stern look.

Aiden nodded. "Fine."

Keir snorted. "Yeah, we'll see how long that lasts. Don't make me take her from you guys, because I will."

I laughed at him, knowing Lilly would never let him control her like that, but I let him think he had the upper hand for now. He was right, though. We needed to ease up on Lilly so she could focus on getting ready for the trials. She had to survive them. If that meant backing off a little for the time being, it was a sacrifice we'd willingly make.