25. Chapter 24

CHAPTER 24

COLTON

J ustin lifted our baby girl into his arms and walked toward the bedroom. The level of excitement that ran through me was akin to the first time Justin and I were together. When you find the people you are meant to be with, nothing can compare. Looking back on life, I'll never think, Damn, I was a really hard worker or a pretty good friend. I want to look back on life and remember moments like these.

He lovingly placed her in the middle of the bed and climbed up, hovering over her. I couldn't hear what he whispered in her ear, but it didn't matter. Anything he said to her was meant for all of us.

Justin covered her body in gentle kisses as she murmured her pleasure. I walked to the nightstand, pulling out a bottle of lube, and gave her a wink. Even in her current state, her eyebrows rose just enough to show me she needed this as much as I did.

"Colton, take your clothes off."

I gave a small nod and threw the bottle next to Riley on the bed. The worn button-down shirt I had on worked perfectly to tease my man, but hell if it wasn't driving me crazy, too. The slower I went for either of them, the more agonizing it felt. I slipped one hand into my still-open jeans, gripping my cock as my other hand unbuttoned my shirt.

"He's so beautiful, isn't he?"

"That he is, baby girl."

Riley bit her lip as Justin lay next to her. She reached for her breast, the same one I had given a little love bite to only moments earlier, and caressed her hard nipples.

"And you think I'm beautiful?" I asked as I undid the last button and pulled off my shirt.

"You are, but so is she," Justin said, leaning over Riley and stealing a quick kiss before slipping his fingers between her legs. "Enjoying the show?"

"I am," she groaned as I slid my jeans off and threw them to the chair in the corner. "Take it all off and come to me, please, Colton."

I smiled to myself as I did as she asked. The look in her eyes made it impossible to deny her. I pumped my cock as I approached and lay alongside her, pulling her soft body to mine.

She immediately crawled on top of me, and Justin grasped my hands, then pinned my arms above my head. My dick was rock-hard and pressed against my lower stomach as she ground herself against me. Her hands slid up my arms to mine, stretching her body over me and positioning her breasts right in front of my face. I caught her nipple in my mouth, sucking hard as she took her pleasure.

I felt the movement of the bed as Justin shifted his position. Clothing rustled against skin before I heard the click of the lube cap opening. Everything that was happening between us distracted Riley, but I knew exactly what his plans were. It only took a few seconds, but the look in her eyes, and the way her body tensed and then pushed back, left me without a doubt.

"You like that, baby girl? His thick fingers feel good, don't they? "

She nodded quickly, then her body tensed.

"Relax, focus on me," I said. That the first touch always made her panic slightly.

"That's a good girl," Justin praised her. "Follow Colton's instructions and relax your body for me."

She nodded again, this time more deliberately. Moments later, her entire body calmed, and she began rocking forward again, only to lift her ass slightly this time as if asking him for more.

"Talk to me, baby girl. Tell me what you feel."

"I want Colton inside me, but I don't want to rush things," she said as her movements continued. "And your fingers, they are… Fuck, they are amazing."

"Do you want to come for us?"

"Yes."

Riley's hands gripped mine harder as she answered. Almost as if she was trying to contain the orgasm that was slowly taking over her mind and body.

"Can I? Can I come again?" she asked, looking down at me as her hips rocked forward.

It was pure torture. Her lips parted and the most beautiful flush decorated her cheeks. Her eyes fluttered shut momentarily as she fought the enticing pull of her orgasm. She ground down on me again, the head of my cock catching at her entrance. Not only did she want me inside her, I needed to be there. Everything inside me screamed to fuck the living hell out of our baby girl, and yet I waited for Justin to tell us it was time. There was something about his natural dominance that made things just that much sweeter.

"You know I'm not the one to ask," I said with a small smile.

She pushed up on me, turning her head back to Justin as she whined, "Please?"

His chuckle filled the room, and I smiled up at her. When she pressed up, she let my hands go, and I ran them up her sides, cupping her breasts .

"Yes, baby girl. One more time, but the next time is with the both of us deep inside you."

Riley's body took instruction from Justin now. It was as if she didn't even need to think things through. As soon as he gave her permission, she let out the first cry of pleasure and ground herself even harder against me. Her body rocked forward as Justin's movements increased, and I pressed my hips up as she gripped the bedding on either side of my head and screamed. Her body shook and tears welled in her eyes before they closed tightly while she rode out what was left of the pure enjoyment she took and we gave.

Riley collapsed on top of me, and I wrapped my arms around her as Justin got up and undressed. She let out a little sigh as I ran my hands down her back.

"She's so relaxed," I said, watching Justin strip off the rest of his clothes. His dick was hard and long, ready and willing to jump into the mess that Riley and I had become.

"Good, that's just how I want her."

"You're sure you are ready for this, baby girl?" I asked quietly while Justin stood next to the bed, his heated eyes tracing over every inch of our skin like a loving caress.

"I am," she whispered, her eyes glassy as they greedily drank Justin's body in.

"How did I get so lucky?" Justin asked, as I reached out a hand for him.

I always glowed under his praise, but with the comment specifically for me and Riley, it made it even more special. He came to me, and I reached for him as he crawled onto the bed with us. He didn't have a care in the world. So many times I'd wished I had his confidence, but now I know it wasn't ever meant for me when I was alone in this world. It was meant for the both of us. I didn't need to exude confidence; he had enough for both of us. He leaned over Riley, and I felt her hand caress my chest as we kissed. Her love for us together was something that kept me going, even on the darkest days .

"Can I touch you both?"

"Of course, baby," Justin said in between moments of devouring my mouth.

His tongue danced with mine, and I was nearly lost. Then Riley's small hand wrapped around me. It brought me right back to reality, and I groaned.

"How does she always know exactly what we need?" I asked as I pressed my hips forward and ground my cock into her hand.

"Because she's made for us."

We became a pile of mouths and limbs, and before long, I was desperate to come, my body burning with the force of my withheld orgasm.

"It's time," Justin said as he caressed the side of my face.

We both turned to Riley, then I moved up the bed and lay back, pulling her toward me as Justin reached for the lube.

"Remember to relax, baby girl. This will feel different from anything we have done before, but I promise it will be amazing," he said as he coated his fingers in the clear gel.

Riley straddled me, reaching for my cock with her small hands as I held her hips in place. "We are going to go slow. Don't rush us."

She nodded, but I could see the glint in her eye that told me listening to instructions may no longer be an option. I loosened my grip and allowed her to lower herself onto my shaft. The guttural cry that came from her nearly undid me.

"Fuck, you are so wet," I said.

She shifted her hips forward and moved herself in a steady rhythm.

"I told you I was ready."

The wink she gave me hit me deep in my core. I looked over as Justin came up behind her. I leaned forward to catch his mouth over her shoulder, then felt his hands brush my chest. A moment later, he pinched her nipples.

"Colton, play with her clit. I want her needy and ready when I enter her," he said as his hand moved down her side and over her ass.

Just like before, I could tell as soon as his fingers entered her. Riley's body tensed but only for a second before she smiled and leaned forward.

"No teasing. I'm ready. I know I am."

I reached between us and stroked her. Her eyes rolled back, and she let out a small stifled cry as he got into position.

"Very well, baby girl. I won't make you wait any longer."

I played with her carefully, trying my hardest to maintain control. My body was on fire with need, and yet it still wasn't time. Justin took a second to grab more lube, covering himself and pressing some inside her before finally I heard his voice again.

"Exhale."

Riley did what he told her, and I rolled her clit between my fingers gently to distract her. Her eyes went wide, and I reached for the back of her head to catch her gaze.

"Look at me. You are fine, baby. It's always rough at first but give him a second."

She nodded and let out a breath. I could feel him enter her and damn if it wasn't the best thing in the world. The heads of our cocks rubbed together inside her and my jaw clenched as a sharp bolt of pleasure ripped down my spine. She stayed steady, and I brushed kisses across her cheeks and nose. When she closed her eyes, I placed small kisses on her eyelids, and she smiled.

"This is… amazing."

Justin chuckled. "We're just getting started."

I felt him pull back and press forward. The movement caused her walls to tighten around me, and I nearly came right then and there. My hands moved around her, caressing every part of her I could reach, and before long, the three of us hit a tempo that felt like the music of the universe.

"Fuck. Yes," she said through gritted teeth. "I had no idea…it could be so good. "

Her body was already shaking. We didn't have long. I looked past her to Justin and smiled. This was what life was all about. Being completed by the people you loved and never looking back.

"I can't… I…"

Riley's voice cut off as her orgasm hit her. A fine sheen of sweat covered her skin and made her glow. Her eyes were wide this time, as if she didn't want to miss a thing, and as I stared up into them, I stopped trying to hold back. I had nothing to prove. We had forever together.

Her pussy clamped around me, and heat shot through me. Justin's cock was a hot, hard, unrelenting piston, brushing against my cock through that thin dividing wall within Riley. The tingling at the base of my spine became unbearable, and I clamped Riley's hips, grinding her against me. Pleasure exploded, tensing every muscle in my body, whiting out my vision.

"Fuck!" I shouted.

My cum shot out of me in hot spurts deep within her. My mind clouded as Riley rocked her hips, and Justin growled as bliss rendered me numb.

Justin yanked Riley up, wrapping his arms around her, changing the angle of his thrusts. Riley shrieked as she clamped down even tighter on me. I moaned at the sensation, though my cock was spent. Justin groaned and growled out obscenities, pumping his hips even harder. Then finally he closed his eyes, and I reached up and placed my hand over his where he was holding a shaking and moaning Riley in place. His eyes opened and his expression softened as he finally let go.

Riley collapsed on top of me, and Justin held himself over the both of us as I looked up at his handsome face. I stroked my hand down her back, enjoying the way she shuddered at my touch, still lost to the aftershocks of her orgasm.

Never had I thought we'd find someone who fit us so perfectly, but here we were. The trust I had in both of them was staggering, and I wouldn't trade it for the world. Growing up like I did meant there weren't many people in my life I could trust. Sure, I had Justin's family, but even that had taken a while to get used to. Riley was different, though. From the moment she'd come into our lives, I'd felt a pull to her like no one before. I loved her so much. And I loved Justin. They were my everything and no one and nothing could change that.