21. Thomas

THOMAS

Cravings calling …

I got to work early Friday night, feeling like I was on cloud nine. Things were going great with Kenley and Shelby. I wondered how I had ever questioned the fact we could work. Hell, it was hard not to kick myself for it but I didn't want to live in the past. I wanted to look to the future and what that meant for the three of us. I was so busy thinking I wasn't watching where I was going and walked right into something.

"Fuck, man. Something's got your attention and it's not looking where you're going," Chase chuckled.

"Oh, shit. Sorry, Chase. I was daydreaming instead of watching where I'm going."

"Clearly. Could it possibly have something to do with two pretty ladies?"

"Maybe," I laughed.

"I just hope you're paying better attention at the door tonight."

"Don't worry. I'm just here to work on evaluations."

"How are things with Shelby and Kenley?"

"They're amazing. I feel like I've known them forever and been with them for even longer."

"I can understand that. Don't know how you handle two women, though. You're a stronger man than me."

We both chuckled at that. He had a point. I was pretty sure that, at times, it was going to be a lot handling them both. Thankfully, neither one of them was what I would consider to be high maintenance.

"Listen, I have you to thank for this working out how it has. I honestly can't thank you enough. If not for you, I might have walked away from the best thing to ever happen to me."

"I'm just glad I was able to help. It was so obvious to everyone not involved that you three were meant to be together. I just tried nudging you in that direction."

"Well, it worked and somehow they came around too."

"Yeah, you're lucky as fuck," he chuckled. "I don't know about Kenley but, generally, when Shelby makes her mind up about something, she doesn't change it. She must really feel something for you two."

"I hope she does. It hasn't been very long since we decided for good but we got to know each other so well in the process, I think I'm in love with them, Chase."

"If you think you are, I'd say that you are , but being a pussy about it."

"Seriously? That's your advice? Stop being a pussy?"

"Yup. Listen, Thomas, don't you think enough time has been wasted? For all you know, they're waiting for someone else to say it first. They're probably afraid of rejection."

"So am I! If I say it too soon, I could freak one or both of them out and lose them."

"And if you wait too long, they could think you're just not that serious about them. Don't wait on this, man."

"Ugh, you're probably right."

"Of course I am," he laughed. "Now, get to work."

He smirked and walked away, leaving me a lot to think about. Was he right? Would waiting too long cause one of them to end it? Would doing it too soon do the same thing? I had no idea how to figure out what to do. What I knew for sure was that I didn't ever want to be away from them. My life would be nothing without them.

Holy shit, I do love them!

At least that was one part settled. Now I just had to figure out when and how to tell them. First, I wanted to take them on a date that wasn't at one of our homes or at the club. I wasn't sure where I wanted to take them but I was thinking it was time for a vanilla experience. For the time being, though, I had evals to work on. I headed into my office and got to work, Shelby and Kenley never too far from my mind.

By the next morning, I'd figured out where I wanted to take them. I grabbed my phone and brought up our group conversation.

Thomas: Morning, ladies!

Shelby: Hey, handsome. How are you?

Kenley: Morning!

Thomas: I'm great . I want to take you both on a date tonight.

Kenley: Sweet! Seduction, I assume?

Thomas: Nope. We're going to Gramercy Tavern.

Shelby: Wow, we're going fancy tonight! I've always wanted to go there.

Kenley: Isn't that kind of expensive, Thomas?

Thomas: You let me worry about that.

Shelby: Well, I'm in .

Kenley: Me too. I guess we should dress up a little.

Thomas: You'll look beautiful in anything you choose. I'll pick you up around 6, Shelby, and then we'll head to you, Kenley. We have a reservation for 7.

Shelby: Perfect, I'll see you then.

Kenley: I'm excited. See you tonight!

I tossed my phone aside with a smile. Hours later, I was in a pair of black slacks and a burgundy button-down and on my way to Shelby's. She was already on the porch when I got there and my jaw dropped. It was the first I'd ever seen her dressed up for anything but the club. She wore a tight black dress that stopped just above her knees. It went high on her neck with a tasteful cutout, showing a touch of her cleavage. A pair of strappy heels completed the look, showing off her amazing legs. I rushed to get out and open the door. I kissed her gently and helped her into the car.

"You look beautiful, Shelby," I said when I got in the car.

"Thank you. You don't look so bad yourself," she grinned.

I backed out of her driveway and headed for Kenley's place. She was just walking out of the house as I pulled up and Shelby's and my eyes went wide and my jaw dropped for the second time in twenty minutes. She was in a low-cut baby pink dress that flared out at the waist and stopped at her knees. A pair of black heels completed the look, her toned calves accentuated. I was the luckiest fucking man on earth.

"You look gorgeous, Kenley," I said, dropping a gentle kiss on her lips and guiding her into the car.

Our timing was perfect by the time we parked and walked into the restaurant it was spot on 7. The hostess led us to a table near the center of the dining room and I helped the girls into their chairs. They both looked around in awe. The restaurant was elegant as hell and they were easily the most beautiful women in the room. The waiter came over and we each chose the wine pairing and selections on their 5-course menu.

"Thomas, this is so expensive," Kenley whispered.

"And from what I hear, worth every penny. Let's focus on each other, not on how much the meal is going to cost," I said, taking one of their hands in mine.

I was glad I had looked at the menu before I left because I wouldn't have wanted the shock at the prices to have shown on my face. After all, $168 each for the dinner and $98 each for the wine pairing made for a steep bill. I lived a frugal lifestyle, so I could afford this but it was definitely not going to be a regular experience. I noticed the older couple at the table beside us eying our hands but the girls hadn't noticed yet. I hoped they wouldn't.

"It's so beautiful in here," Shelby said, eyes widening when the first course was set on the table.

The plating was out of this world. Shelby's eyes closed and she moaned as the first mouthful hit her tongue. It was erotic as hell and I groaned to myself when my cock twitched in my pants.

Baseball, evaluations, grandma.

I repeated those thoughts in my head until I was in control again.

"This food is out of this world," Kenley said as she cleared her plate.

I realized I'd been so busy watching them, I hadn't even started. She was right. The food was amazing and I couldn't wait for the next course as I took a mouthful of wine. I made sure to hold their hands between the courses and by the third, the couple beside us were looking at us with disgust. Kenley noticed first and paled a little, pulling her hand from mine. Shelby followed her line of sight and narrowed her eyes, holding my hand even tighter.

"Kenley, remember what we decided?" Shelby said, reaching over to take her hand.

"We don't give a shit what people think."

"Exactly," I agreed, taking her other hand.

"You're right. A couple of ignorant people aren't going to ruin our night out at an amazing restaurant," Kenley said, spine straightening as she shot them a dirty look.

The couple quickly looked away, seemingly embarrassed about being caught staring. The rest of our meal passed without issue and by the time we finished the dessert course, we were all full as hell. It had been worth every penny. It was also a very good test for how we would handle judgmental people when we came across them. I was sure that Kenley wouldn't be uncertain next time. I was honestly surprised that Shelby hadn't told them off. I suspected in a less formal place, she might have.

"Would you ladies like to come back to my place?"

They nodded in agreement, and I paid the bill, leading them to the car. We chatted on the way home and I couldn't help but stare at their asses as they walked up the path to the front door.

"Like what you see?" Shelby smirked.

I hadn't even noticed her look back at me and my cheeks flushed a little.

"As a matter of fact, I do," I chuckled.

I unlocked the door, ushered them in, and then kissed each of them gently. They walked through to the living room and sat on the couch. We chatted for a little bit until I couldn't wait anymore.

"I love you," I blurted.

Their eyes widened and I smiled.

"I do. I love you both and I don't care if it's too soon to say it. I want you to know how I feel."

"Thomas—I?—"

"Shelby, you don't have to say anything," I said gently.

"I love you too," Kenley said. "I've been thinking about it for a while but didn't want to say it first."

Shelby looked at each of us and smiled.

"I do too but I admit, it scares the shit out of me that I feel so much so quickly."

"That's okay," Kenley reassured. "We haven't. exactly done any of this in a way that makes sense. There's no reason this should be any different."

We all chuckled at that and I realized she was right. It didn't matter that we felt it and said it so soon. Somehow, I think we knew all along that we were meant to be together, we were just too afraid to admit it. It had actually been a few months since this had all started.

I squeezed their hands and pulled them to stand with me. My lips crashed against Shelby's first and then Kenley's as I led them to my bedroom. Shelby eased the zipper down on Kenley's dress as I unzipped hers. I looked at them in awe as they let the fall and stepped out of them. They both wore lacy bras and thongs, their curves on full display. Their long dark hair fell to their waists and I couldn't wait to have them.

Kenley stepped up to Shelby and kissed her with so much passion that my dick swelled. Shelby broke the kiss and grinned at me as she unbuttoned my shirt. She pushed it off my shoulders and I pulled my arms out of it, letting it fall to the floor with their dresses. Kenley reached to unfasten my pants and then drew those and my boxers down my legs.

I watched as she fell to her knees in front of me and took hold of my hard shaft. She pumped it up and down a couple of times and then licked around the tip, moaning as my precum hit her tongue. Her mouth descended slowly onto me and I groaned as she sucked gently as she bobbed her head up and down. I was torn between watching her giving me a blow job or watching Shelby who had shed her bra and was now playing with her tits. I gently pushed her hands away and then palmed the large mounds, pinching her nipples. I looked back at Kenley when she fondled my balls and sucked me harder. I quickly withdrew from her mouth and chuckled at her pout.

"There's no way I'm coming down your throat, sweetheart. I have other plans for tonight."

I led them to the bed, pulled off the rest of their clothes, and had Shelby lay down on it. Kenley grinned as she realized what I had in mind. I climbed over Shelby and kissed her gently before pulling Kenley to straddle her head. Shelby moaned as she ran her tongue through Kenley's folds. I moved down the bed and licked her pussy from her entrance to her clit. She cried out, muffled by Kenley. I watched as her tongue flicked against Kenley's clit and I mimicked her motions. In minutes they were both crying out what would be their first releases of the night.

Kenley moved to lay beside Shelby, playing with her tits as I climbed over Shelby again. Shelby shuddered as I ran my cock from her tight bud right up to her clit, circling the head around it. I slowly pushed into her tight channel until I bottomed out, giving her a couple of moments to get used to my girth before I thrust gently in and out of her.

"Fuck, Thomas, you feel so good," she cried. "Kenley, don't stop."

I made slow, passionate love to her smiling as she bumped her hips against mine. I knew she wanted me to speed up but I wanted her to feel the love I felt for her. I was quickly approaching my own release as I drove her toward her own. I reached over to play with Kenley's clit as I pumped in and out of Shelby. They panted as I tried to hold off my own orgasm. Unable to wait any longer, I pinched Kenley's clit, prompting her climax as I thrust hard into Shelby, my arousal painting the walls of her pussy. She came hard around my cock as I fell forward, my head buried in the crook of her neck.

I leaned over to kiss Kenley and then kissed Shelby before falling to her side.

"Fuck, I love you both so much."

"I love you too," Shelby said softly. "Both of you."

"So do I. I'm so happy we figured things out, even if it took a long time," Kenley laughed.

I linked hands with Kenley over Shelby's waist and the three of us fell into a peaceful sleep.