44. Olivia

Olivia

A volcano seems to erupt inside me. My darkness purrs within me, demanding I fuck my men.

The thought of being with all five of them at once makes my pussy clench so hard it has me whimper with need. I’ve imagined this moment earlier and while I didn’t think it would happen tonight, I need all of them so much right now.

Someone inhales deeply just as I say, “Please.” I went from hating men touching me and fucking me to begging my bondeds for cock.

Mose pushes my panties to the side, his fingers entering me. “So. Wet.” My hips rock against his hand, feeling his thick digits sink deeper inside me.

Yes, I’m already so wet for all of them. My fingers dig into the ground beneath me. The need to touch them has my darkness release me from the rope tying my wrists together.

I reach out my hands, but before I can touch them, fingers wrap around my flesh and pull my arms above my head.

“You’re our captive, and you’re not supposed to try and seduce us,” Rueben rasps into my ear.

Oh, we’re playing a game? “Not even a little bit?” I wonder.

“She is indeed meant to be our wife,” Jasper chuckles. “We are lucky we found her in the forest.”

For a moment, I fear that they will propose right now, but when Ansel lets go of my nipple only to capture my mouth in a rough kiss, I know they only have one thing on their minds—to make me scream out their names while my body is high with pleasure.

Ansel’s tongue darts inside my mouth just as Mose yanks out his fingers from inside me, dives his face between my legs, and kisses my pussy.

Rueben lets go of my hands. “Maybe we should let you show us why we should take you home with us,” he finally decides to let me play the seductress part instead of being a starfish while they take turns fucking me.

My fingers lace through Tyson’s hair, and I yank him toward my mouth, not caring that I’m still kissing Ansel. Tyson seems to hesitate for a moment before pressing his lips to my jaw and leaving a trail of kisses on his way to my neck. He licks my skin while his palm rubs against my nipple.

Mose keeps kissing my pussy, his warm breath fluttering against my clit, making me squirm. My pussy keeps clenching, and I want him to flip me on my hands and knees and fill me with his cock.

Ansel’s mouth returns to my other tit, making me beg even more, “I’ll be good, but please—”

I don’t get to finish as my head is tilted backwards, and hot lips press against mine. The blindfold still prevents me from seeing who it is, but by his sweet taste, it isn’t hard to guess who’s kissing me—Rueben. I reach above my head, and my hands lock against the back of his neck as our tongues meet in a slow dance.

Big raindrops suddenly start falling from the sky, making the guys swear loudly. The unforeseen change of weather seems to have ruined their plans of fucking me on the grass, but I don’t mind the rain. I love it just as much as the snow.

Mose seems just as unbothered as me, as he keeps planting kisses all over my pussy, but Ansel and Tyson stop teasing me. My breasts feel heavy, and all I want is their hands and mouths back on them.

Rueben lifts his head. “Did anyone bother to check the weather?” he snarls angrily.

No one answers. I feel him getting up.

Thunder rumbles in the distance.

“We should get inside the house before we catch a cold or something worse,” Jasper says. It’s been years since I last felt the rain on my skin, and I want to stay out more. Still lying on the ground, I part my lips and let the drops fall into my mouth. “Olivia is yet to make a full recovery from her pneumonia.” The rest agree with him, but I don’t. My darkness will keep me safe from any illness.

Mose, peeling away from me, tells me what I must do.

I finally remove the blindfold. We are relatively close to the cabin, and the light coming from the porch is enough to let me see around me.

Jasper leans forward. Knowing that he wants to pick me up, I grab him by the front of his shirt and pull him on top of me. “I want to dance in the rain,” I say before I push him on his back and I straddle him. “I want you all to make love to me while the rain falls around us.”

“Little Love—” Jasper starts to protest, but whatever else he has to say is lost as I rub my pussy up and down his hard erection, and he groans in pleasure.

I lower the straps of my dress, revealing my tits. Jasper eagerly covers them with his big palms.

Tyson kneels between Jasper’s legs, his chest pressed against my back. “It’s not fair to use your charms to seduce us,” he murmurs against my neck.

But I want to seduce them, to make them feel like they can’t live without me, because, God Almighty, that’s how I feel. Like I can’t breathe if they are not with me. How pathetic am I to be so emotionally dependent on them? But this is how I’ve always been, even when I pretended to be strong.

The others kneel around us. “Take off your clothes,” I rasp, eager to feel them inside me. If I could take all five of them at once inside my body, I would.

Ansel, Rueben, and Mose quickly do as I ask while I slowly unbutton Jasper’s shirt. His hands caress my tits, causing goosebumps to erupt all over my skin. Or is it because of the rain?

Behind me, Tyson ditches his clothes before he pulls back my wet hair and kisses the column of my neck.

“I want both of you inside me right now.” My voice sounds just as urgent as I feel.

“I don’t think your pussy can accommodate the both of us,” Jasper chuckles.

I hesitate only for one moment before I say, “I want to try anal.”

No one says anything. Probably because they know how badly I was hurt in the past, but it will be different this time. My body wants them. I want them.

The rain keeps falling around us, the sound of the drops hitting the ground swallowing the sound of our breaths. Why isn’t anyone saying anything? I thought they would be ecstatic to finally fuck my ass.

The guys look at me, their expressions unreadable.

My fingers tremble against Jasper’s buttons. I doubt it is because of the rain because I don’t feel cold at all.

The silence continues and I start to feel nauseated.

Maybe they don’t want to fuck my ass because of what was done to me in the past. I shouldn’t have said anything and let them ravage my mouth and pussy.

Tyson is the first to speak. “Olly.” He sounds calm but the bond lets me know how excited he is. He wants this just as much as I do. So do the others. I need to stop overthinking things. Tyson’s hands slide between us, and he grabs my ass. “I’ll be gentle.”

But I don’t want him to be gentle. I want him to remove all traces of those who used me for their own pleasure while mocking the tears falling down my cheeks. I want to be fucked hard and rough. I want to be loved, not gently and sweetly, but fiercely and passionately.

Rueben snorts. “Gentle, my ass.” He shakes his head before adding, “Just don’t ruin this for everyone else.”

“Maybe we should wait until we get her ready. If we DP her right now, we might hurt her,” Ansel protests.

My fingers reach the last button of Jasper’s shirt. “I just don’t want to feel them inside me anymore.” Tears blur my vision or maybe it’s the rain falling on my face. “I don’t care if it hurts or not…” I stop talking before my voice cracks.

They finally realize why I need them so badly—so they can fuck away any trace of those who violated my body, mind, and soul.

Tyson kisses my shoulder. “I’m going to find the Celestial Heaven and burn it to the ground while the Dukes are locked inside.”

I’ll be the one to light the matches. His warm breath against my skin spreads across my body and I stop trembling.

“We’re going to take good care of you,” Tyson promises.

I lean forward and kiss Jasper while I open his fly. His tongue seeks entrance but I let him coax me a little more before I open for him and we taste each other while my hands cover his cock. I squeeze him the way he likes it and he groans against my mouth.

“I knew you were special from the moment we found you,” Jasper murmurs against my lips. “My demon as well. He wanted to bond with you right away.”

I have been angry with him for a long time just because he wanted to have babies with me but I overlooked everything he did for me. Not anymore. My heart is so full of love for him.

His cock throbs against my palms. “I want you,” I say as I lift my hips and position myself above his dick. “All of you,” I correct myself as I impale myself on Jasper.

Even after being fucked so many times by him, my body still tries to resist his invasion. Tonight, he feels bigger than ever, and I whimper as my pussy is forced wide open.

Jasper thrusts up gently, burying more of himself inside me, knocking the breath out of me. Between gritted teeth, he says, “You’re so damn tight.”

He almost sounds like he doesn’t like it. Maybe it hurts for him? I try to force my body to relax. The frown between his eyes slowly disappears as he slides all the way up inside me.

“That’s it, Little Love, let me in so I can show you how much I love you,” Jasper coos.

Rueben and Ansel are closer to me and I reach out my hands to touch them. There’s no more anger inside my soul for them. Accepting them as mine has been the best decision I have ever made. My fingers caress their cocks, and they throw their heads back like my touch is too overwhelming.

Tyson pushes down my dress and panties, exposing my ass. “I don’t have lube,” he warns me while he runs his fingers between my butt cheeks. I don’t care about that. “Relax,” he says before he plunges two fingers inside my mouth. He pumps them in and out of me a few times before moving them to my ass and gently pushing one finger inside me. There’s a slight sensation of discomfort, but nothing I can’t handle.

Jasper’s left hand slips between us, and his thumb circles my clit, distracting me from what Tyson is doing. But I don’t need any distractions. Not with them. I want to feel every thrust, every touch, every kiss they give me.

Rueben grabs my free tit, his fingers tweaking my nipple.

Tyson pushes another finger inside my ass.

Jasper’s cock throbs inside me. I slowly rock my hips but Tyson grabs my waist. “Stay still until I get you ready,” he says.

I shake my head. “I need you now.”

“Olivia,” he tries to warn me, but I’m too stubborn.

My hands move up and down Rueben and Ansel’s cocks. “I don’t want to wait any longer.” Tyson lets out a long sigh before pulling out his fingers and guiding his cock to my ass. “And I want Mose’s cock inside my mouth.”

Mose moves between Jasper and Ansel, his dick pointing at my face. I part my lips and take him in. He tastes like the rain. Like freedom. I eagerly suck his cock, wanting his essence to flood my mouth.

When did I become such a cum-slut?

Tyson slowly pushes his cock in and out of my ass. I involuntarily clench around him and Jasper.

Tyson presses his lips to my cheek. “If you are this tense, it will hurt,” he murmurs.

I focus only on how my men make me feel and not on the past. My body opens for Tyson, letting him inside me, the pain turning into pleasure.

It’s been a while since all my holes were used at the same time but I feel so full, so stretched out, and in a good way. Tyson kisses the column of my neck while fucking me gently. I whimper around Mose’s cock, because it feels better than I imagined, especially when Jasper moves as well.

My moans make Mose grab my wet hair and put a hand under my chin and he starts to fuck my mouth. I run my tongue against his piercings, making him fuck my throat harder. I used to hate giving blowjobs, but now I love them.

When Tyson is balls deep inside me, Jasper says, “Fuck. This is…fuck.” His groans are louder than the rain. He keeps speaking. “Tyson, I can…feel you.”

“Yeah. It’s…crazy,” Tyson grunts as he grinds his hips against me, his cock rubbing against Jasper’s through the thin wall separating them. Maybe he wanted to say hot? Because it is so fucking hot.

These two men, who I love so much, are too stubborn to admit they have feelings for each other. But it is not me who says, “Just kiss already,” but Ansel, as my mouth is still full of Mose’s cock.

Tyson stops moving and protests. “I’m not…Olivia, she won’t—”

Jasper grabs Tyson by the back of his neck and their lips meet in the middle. Tyson stiffens only for a few moments before kissing Jasper back. They fuck me harder, making me moan. Mose’s breathing becomes ragged.

“About damn time,” Rueben says.

Ansel speaks next. “That is hot.” Since I agree with both of them, I jerk them off faster.

Tyson and Jasper keep kissing, their cocks sending wave after wave of pleasure crashing through my body. I want to join their kiss, but Mose is not done with me. I tighten my throat around him, wanting to make him come.

“Shit,” Mose snarls. A few more thrusts and he finishes down my throat. His cock remains inside my mouth a little longer, and I gently suck him until he pulls out seconds later.

Jasper stops kissing Tyson only for a moment. “I never thought this day would come.” His voice is thick with emotions, reflecting his deep love for Tyson. How long has he felt this way and never dared to say something?

“I…this is strange…I’ve only ever loved Olivia…and now…I…” Tyson mumbles.

Does Tyson think I’d be against him being with Jasper, and this is why he never acted on his feelings? I bring my mouth close to their faces. “Nothing would make me happier than to see both of you loving each other. Life is too short to have regrets,” I say before I kiss them. It’s a very strange kiss, but it reflects our bond and feelings.

They keep fucking me, while our mouths devour each other. Jasper keeps teasing my clit, while their cocks ram inside me, making me feel a pleasure that I’ve never dreamed of. Their piercings rub against the right spots inside me, and my legs start to tremble.

My pussy and ass clamp around them as I come hard. My hands let go of Ansel and Rueben and I wrap them around Jasper’s back, my fingernails sinking into his flesh.

“Fuck,” Tyson swears as his cock shoots rope after rope of cum inside my ass.

Jasper grunts my name as he fills my pussy with his essence.

We keep kissing until Ansel says, “Rueben and I are dying of blue balls. You can keep kissing after we fuck Olivia.”

Tyson is reluctant to pull out, but as the rain grows heavier and the drops turn cold, he gets up. Ansel puts his arms around my waist, his palms grabbing the inside of my thighs and he stands, my back to him. Rueben stands in front of us, a strange look on his face.

My body throbs after being fucked so hard by Jasper, Tyson, and Mose, but I still crave to be with Ansel and Rueben.

Ansel’s cock enters my ass and starts pistoning inside me. He feels just as good as Tyson. “I won’t last but I want to feel you rippling around me when I shoot my load up your perfect ass.”

I whimper, looking into Rueben’s turquoise eyes, who is still not moving. “I need you, too.”

A growl leaves Rueben before stepping forward and grabbing my face between his palms. My legs wrap around him. “I’ve never loved anyone except you,” he confesses before he enters my pussy. He feels like the missing piece of the puzzle, and I finally feel complete. “Olivia…”

My body glows so brightly that it engulfs all of us.

I press my lips to Rueben’s mouth, our kiss slow and gentle. I’ve never been happier or more full of love than I am right now.

Ansel and Rueben fuck my sensitive body hard, and it doesn’t take long for me to have another orgasm. Moments later, they come as well. The light returns to my body.

I lean my forehead against Rueben’s shoulder. “Who wants to dance with me first?”

“We should go inside,” Jasper protests.

Rueben and Ansel lower my feet to the ground.

“Tyson, do you remember the first time we danced under the stars?” I ask, ignoring Jasper’s words. Tyson nods. “I want to see you dance with Jasper the same way you did with me,” I tell him.

Tyson is still hesitant, but Jasper seems more open. “I’ve been longing in secret for years. If not for Olivia’s reassurance and the others pushing me from behind, I would have never had the courage to kiss you, but now that I have done so, I can finally confess my feelings to you. Dance with me.”