As a member of Cider Falls Coven, Sienna wields a unique power that allows her and her fellow witches to control the egos of mortal men. For centuries, they have created a peaceful haven for all who reside in Cider Falls.

But when Forrest, a rugged stranger, arrives to open a sports bar in their town, the usual spell fails to work on him. Unsure of what they may be facing, Sienna's coven asks her to keep a watchful eye on Forrest. Her task is not too taxing, given his insatiable cravings for the pastries from her bakery.

As Sienna and Forrest spend more time together, a surprising bond forms between them. But when Forrest reveals his true intentions for coming to Cider Falls, Sienna must decide whether she can trust him.

Navigating hidden agendas and long-buried secrets, Sienna will do anything to protect those she loves and the town she calls home.